When December rolls around, Miami is buzzing with anticipation for stone crab season, which runs from mid-October to mid-May. Stone crab claws are a delicacy unique to Florida, prized for their sweet, tender meat and sustainable harvesting practices. Whether you’re a longtime fan or new to the experience, here’s your guide to the best spots in Miami to savor this iconic seafood dish.
What Makes Stone Crab Special?
Stone crabs are unique because only their claws are harvested and returned to the ocean to regrow. This sustainable practice ensures a steady supply year after year. In Miami, stone crab claws are typically served chilled with mustard sauce, though you’ll find creative variations across the city.
Tips for Enjoying Stone Crab in December
- Know Your Sizes: Stone crab claws come in medium, large, jumbo, and colossal sizes. Larger claws are meatier but have a higher price tag.
- Peak Freshness: December is prime time for stone crabs, as the season is in full swing and claws are at their freshest.
- Pair It Right: Enjoy your claws with a crisp white wine, like a Sauvignon Blanc, or a refreshing craft beer.
- Order Early: Stone crab claws are highly sought after, so restaurants can sell out quickly. Call ahead to ensure availability.
1. Joe’s Stone Crab
Location: South Beach
Why It’s a Must: A Miami institution since 1913, Joe’s Stone Crab is the definitive spot for stone crab lovers. Known for its impeccable service and legendary mustard dipping sauce, it’s a bucket-list experience for anyone visiting or living in Miami.
Insider Tip: The restaurant’s no-reservation policy often means a wait. For a quicker experience, try Joe’s Take Away, located right next door.
2. Monty’s Raw Bar
Location: Coconut Grove and South Beach
Why It’s a Must: With waterfront views and a laid-back atmosphere, Monty’s offers a more casual yet equally delicious stone crab experience. Their fresh claws pair perfectly with a tropical cocktail as you enjoy Miami’s breezy December evenings.
Pro Tip: Visit for discounted claws and a lively crowd during happy hour.
3. Truluck’s Ocean’s Finest Seafood & Crab
Location: Brickell
Why It’s a Must: Truluck flies in fresh stone crab claws daily from their own fisheries in Florida. The upscale ambiance and extensive wine list make it an excellent spot for a special night out.
What to Order: Pair your claws with their signature Lobster Bisque for a luxurious meal.
4. Garcia’s Seafood Grille & Fish Market
Location: Miami River
Why It’s a Must: A local favorite, Garcia’s serves some of the freshest seafood in Miami straight from their fish market. The rustic waterfront setting and affordable pricing make it a standout choice for stone crab enthusiasts.
Insider Tip: Sit outside to enjoy views of the Miami River while you dine.
5. The Original Crab House
Location: North Miami Beach
Why It’s a Must: This hidden gem is perfect for those seeking quality stone crab without the crowds. Known for generous portions and friendly service, it’s a favorite among locals who want great seafood without breaking the bank.
Don’t Miss: Try their seafood platters to sample a variety of shellfish alongside your claws.
6. Rusty Pelican
Location: Key Biscayne
Why It’s a Must: Famous for its panoramic views of the Miami skyline, Rusty Pelican pairs stunning scenery with expertly prepared stone crab claws. It’s an ideal location for a romantic dinner or holiday celebration.
What to Order: Start with the stone crab claws and follow up with their Caribbean-inspired seafood dishes.
7. Captain’s Tavern
Location: Kendall
Why It’s a Must: This old-school seafood spot has served Miami since 1971 and is a go-to for fresh stone crab claws without the glitz and glam. The focus here is on great food at reasonable prices.
Pro Tip: Their stone crab claws are often available in various sizes, so you can tailor your order to your appetite.
Make It a Tradition
December is one of the best times to experience stone crab in Miami, whether dining al fresco by the water or indulging at a fine dining establishment. With its unique flavor, sustainability, and cultural significance, stone crab is more than just a meal—it’s a Miami tradition.
Tell us your favorite spot to enjoy stone crab, or tag us in your foodie photos!